Votes are pretty close, 8 to 7, looks like over all both stories are like whilst A is favoured due to it being more close to the original.

Anyone have anything new to bring to the discussion?

A sounds nice too. I like the test chamber destroying idea. :) But I just HATE Behind The Scenes. That was the most boring part in Portal. So usually I don't play map packs that have alot BTS. And BTS is kinda creepy too. I don't like it :<

So if you plan to make the story B with a text explaining the story, which I absolutely doubt of course, just forget about B. It's not interesting at all if that's the case.

Hurricaaane wrote:
In story B, you have to make the player understand the story, whereas A seems natural in Portal flow.
It involves more of a classical Half Life 2 story with choreography with NPCs encounters. And a lot of voice acting.

So if you plan to make the story B with a text explaining the story, which I absolutely doubt of course, just forget about B. It's not interesting at all if that's the case.

I know its a whole load more work, thats why I wan't to get other people more involved in this so we can pull it off. It would turn into a full scale mod with people making props, textures, character models, voice actors..
Option B is to make a more traditional story and I would make sure it ends up that rather than leaving it half assed.

That's about the summary of HAL.

In light of atsu's offer I think the test subject just got younger

youme wrote:
In light of atsu's offer I think the test subject just got younger

:O

youme wrote:
I know its a whole load more work, thats why I wan't to get other people more involved in this so we can pull it off. It would turn into a full scale mod with people making props, textures, character models, voice actors..
Option B is to make a more traditional story and I would make sure it ends up that rather than leaving it half assed.

i might be able to headhack some citizen heads onto kleiner... but ive never headhacked before, so we'll see how that goes

And btw you serious with that one thing? :p

I'm not deciding either way just yet and my signature indicates work on storyline A

I think after GLaDOS said "... is a perfect time to have her tested." Everyone in Aperture Science decided to not bring their daughters. :D

I think it's time I found someone to write a script for each with so I can properly decide one way or the other

youme wrote:
I think it's time I found someone to write a script for each with so I can properly decide one way or the other

cough hint cough hint cough