The Great Portal 2 Speculation Thread

Avatar
WinstonSmith
940 Posts
Posted Oct 09, 2010
Replied 23 minutes later

msleeper wrote:
Mr. Happy wrote:

Also, she was originally designed for something to do with ice.

Citation needed.

Portal content.gcf/portal/materials/slides/slide1.vtf. Frame 3.

Advertisement
Registered users don't see ads! Register now!
Avatar
msleeper
4,095 Posts
Member
Posted Oct 09, 2010
Replied 7 minutes later
Well played. :3
Avatar
Maxpm
8 Posts
Posted Oct 10, 2010
Replied 20 hours later
Hmm.
||We're going to need to kill Wheatley, or we will see him die. As much as I don't want that to happen, there's no way Valve is going to pass up the opportunity.

At the end of Portal, GLaDOS said something along the lines of "Things have changed since you last left the building," as well as several other references to the Combine invasion. This leads me to believe the backdrop of Portal 2 will be one of three things:

1) Hundreds of years after the Ep. 2 rocket successfully wiped out the Combine. Happy ending, everything's fine.

2a) The rocket didn't work, and the Combine have killed off the last of the humans.

2b) Same as 2a, except the Combine have long since come and gone. They got what they were looking for, so they're abandoning Earth (which is now a wasteland).

On a side note, do you guys think the Rat Man will be involved in any way?||

Avatar
SL89
35 Posts
Posted Oct 11, 2010
Replied 11 hours later
I'll place my thoughts!
My Thoughts
so Half Life is out of the way and everything is fine. AP is forgotten and you have to ally with Wheatly to get around. He is manipulated by GLaDOS to do something evil. he finds the Co-op bots and convinces them to lure you to a deadly place where you have the final boss fight.You kill them and run out of the building. Happy Ending!
Avatar
ASBusinessMagnet
490 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 5 days later

How big do you think is the probability that Valve will keep up the Portal story arc as their "next best thing" and completely abandon Half-Life 2: Episode Three that we have been waiting for for so long?

What I personally think will happen is:

  1. Portal 2, Ms. Johnson-Rattmann (good luck figuring out what I mean by this) and/or the co-op bots seriously fuck up Aperture Science facilities and cause the end of time. "End" of Portal arc.

  2. Half-Life 2: Episode Three, see Episode Three speculated storyline. (Only the Episode Three part, I'm continuing the thing differently.)

  3. Half-Life 3 and followups, G-Man places Gordon and his crew (Alyx, the Vortigaunts, etc.) in stasis and releases them near the end of time that Portal 2 causes. Then Gordon and his crew must prevent the end of time from happening and continue both the Half-Life and Portal arcs.

Avatar
msleeper
4,095 Posts
Member
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 10 minutes later
None of that makes any sense.

Episode 3 and the HL2 storyline will not interset with Portal 2. The devs have flat out stated this.

Avatar
ASBusinessMagnet
490 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 5 minutes later

msleeper wrote:
None of that makes any sense.

Episode 3 and the HL2 storyline will not interset with Portal 2. The devs have flat out stated this.

Well how many years we will have to wait until the Half-Life 3 I predicted comes?

Things may change greatly. Hell, HL3 may not even happen. (What Valve will do then?)

Avatar
msleeper
4,095 Posts
Member
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 12 minutes later
They've also said that the episodes "are HL3".
Avatar
ASBusinessMagnet
490 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 9 minutes later

msleeper wrote:
They've also said that the episodes "are HL3".

If the episodes are HL3, is HL3 (the follow-up of the episodes) HL4?

Might want to edit the post to reflect that.

Avatar
youme
937 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 35 minutes later

ASBusinessMagnet wrote:
msleeper wrote:

They've also said that the episodes "are HL3".

If the episodes are HL3, is HL3 (the follow-up of the episodes) HL4?

Might want to edit the post to reflect that.

No, they have also stated that episode 3 is the end of the Gordon Freeman story arc.

Probably why it is still completely and utterly unannounced.

Avatar
hanging_rope
435 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 11 minutes later
No, they stated that episode 3 is the end of the combine story arc.
Avatar
WinstonSmith
940 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 3 hours later

hanging_rope wrote:
No, they stated that episode 3 is the end of the combine story arc.

Quite honestly, I would think this would entail the end of Gordon's time on the silver monitor. It doesn't seem like VALVe would bring other antagonists in ("Gordon vs. Mothra", anyone?), and I highly doubt we'll see Gordon anywhere in the Portal storyline, especially since, as has been pointed out multiple times, the two storylines will not in any major way intersect.

Also, I was unaware that Ep3 would be the final installment. I'm now rather sad, as I assumed VALVe would want to go out on a big note instead of the smaller episodic [grace] note. I know the episodes are intended to make up a full game, but when they're separated it dilutes the experience a bit.

And finally, ASBusinessMagnet, a great deal of your posts scare me.

Avatar
youme
937 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 33 minutes later

hanging_rope wrote:
No, they stated that episode 3 is the end of the combine story arc.

Can you provide a source? Because I definitely remember it being Gordon's arc that was ending. After all, the end of the combine arc is the end of half life full stop since they're the driving force behind even the original game.

Avatar
WinstonSmith
940 Posts
Posted Oct 16, 2010
Replied 1 hour later

youme wrote:
hanging_rope wrote:

No, they stated that episode 3 is the end of the combine story arc.

Can you provide a source? Because I definitely remember it being Gordon's arc that was ending. After all, the end of the combine arc is the end of half life full stop since they're the driving force behind even the original game.

My point exactly.

Avatar
hanging_rope
435 Posts
Posted Oct 17, 2010
Replied 17 hours later

youme wrote:
hanging_rope wrote:

No, they stated that episode 3 is the end of the combine story arc.

Can you provide a source? Because I definitely remember it being Gordon's arc that was ending. After all, the end of the combine arc is the end of half life full stop since they're the driving force behind even the original game.

That maybe so. I can't really find where I read that, probably some interview. According to wikipedia, it will be "The end of the story arc".
I'm pretty sure that means the end of the combine domination of earth, but it could be that Gordon is ending. IDK

Avatar
msleeper
4,095 Posts
Member
Posted Oct 17, 2010
Replied 1 hour later
Things may have changed in the interim time, but yeah, I remember hearing this stuff at least several years ago in interviews.
Avatar
NunamedDragon
39 Posts
Posted Oct 18, 2010
Replied 7 hours later
There will no longer be cake....
Avatar
p0rtalplayer
1,366 Posts
Posted Oct 18, 2010
Replied 14 hours later
Well unless episode 3 has a lot of explaining to do, I don't think it can satisfactorily explain the end of the combine reign.

First off unless the Borealis contains something equivalent to what the Nuke was in WWII, it's not going to help the rebels beat the combine at all. It might be a good boost towards that goal but I can't see the whole world being liberated in a single game.

Second, I've read some theories that make a lot of sense, specifically one that muses that the G-man is actually trying to use Earth in order to end the combine reign elsewhere in the Universe. This makes sense to me, and if it is close to true, then episode 3 COULD NOT satisfactorily be the end of the combine arc.

Third, half life is Valve's biggest franchise, and Gordon Freeman is half life's biggest character. They can't just get rid of him for their big Half Life game.

Avatar
youme
937 Posts
Posted Oct 18, 2010
Replied 1 hour later

NunamedDragon wrote:
There will no longer be cake....

Yup I can see this. It probably will have some past-tense references but GLaDOS knows that Chell knows there never was any cake or any party. I can't imagine Valve would completely remove the main theme of portal (besides portals) so I'm certain there will still be mentions, but GLaDOS will have moved on, also it would be a bit stale if it was all the same cake humour all over again.
The companion cube is certain to return.

re gordon/combine arc ending: Half life is what defines Valve and I can't see them giving it up easily, but I can see episode 3 being the end of it. Valve aren't the big corporate money grabbers that other companies are, they won't milk Half Life beyond its lifetime (they'll stop half way... ). They may do Half Life without Gordon as the protagonist, and they may do some more with Gordon but without the Combine, HL1 worked without them after all.

Advertisement
Registered users don't see ads! Register now!
Avatar
msleeper
4,095 Posts
Member
Posted Oct 18, 2010
Replied 1 minutes later
Um. Cake wasn't a "main theme" of Portal. And Erik Wolpaw said point blank the CC isn't returning.