2 Map Upload Questions

Avatar
Groxkiller585
652 Posts
Posted Feb 04, 2012
Hello TWP! Haven't been here in awhile due to my leave of mapping but i'm back!

Anywho, I would like to ask if I could post a recent map i've made. Why I am I asking? Well the map is a playground map but there's a catch. It's not a normal playground map.
I've made some things unlockable, and the quality is just like my other maps.

Here's some screens to prove my point:

img

img

img

So can I please put this map up in a thread?

I say thread because this map is so massive the filesize is quite big so I think it would be wise to simply link to a dropbox to save space. If that's a problem I can try uploading it but it might take awhile.

So that's the second question: Can I put a link that is not on TWP to the map DL?

Advertisement
Registered users don’t see ads! Register now!
Avatar
angelsl
34 Posts
Posted Feb 05, 2012
Replied 5 hours later
Why not just upload it, because if it's that good it won't get removed.

And you can; tick the External checkbox and enter the URL to the download in the field.

Avatar
Groxkiller585
652 Posts
Posted Feb 05, 2012
Replied 9 hours later

angelsl wrote:
Why not just upload it, because if it's that good it won't get removed.

And you can; tick the External checkbox and enter the URL to the download in the field.

Well I asked because I remember a very strict policy about playground maps, quality or not, so I wanted to be sure it would be ok to upload it.

Avatar
Idolon
417 Posts
Posted Feb 05, 2012
Replied 2 hours later

msleeper wrote:
- Maps with no lighting (fullbright maps)
- "Playground" or sandbox type maps (assuming they are of general poor quality on their own, see above)
- Maps with no goal, puzzle or objective

I'd say you're in the clear, as this looks high-quality and I would consider unlocking an objective.

Avatar
Spam Nugget
492 Posts
Posted Feb 05, 2012
Replied 1 hour later

msleeper wrote:
If a "playground" map is of sufficient quality - and by that I mean, it's not a single box room with fullbright and 1 texture - then I won't have a problem with it. The ones that were removed were nothing more, or not much more, than that though.

EDIT
The goal is not to stifle creativity or make a "No Fun Allowed" rule; we want to make sure that visitors know that TWP will continue to have some of the best quality Portal 2 maps on the internet. I have full faith that one of our many talented community members could make a "playground" map, and make it look good.

In fact, consider that a challenge. Anyone who thinks they can make a playground map that is also a "high quality download", do your best. I dare you.

I'd say you're in the clear mate.

Avatar
ChickenMobile
2,460 Posts
Posted Feb 05, 2012
Replied 4 hours later
as previously mentioned by msleeper she likes pretty maps so I doubt this would be deleted at all.
Avatar
kwp21 pitts
260 Posts
Posted Feb 05, 2012
Replied 1 hour later
Got a little worried when I saw playground in the description, but I won't know until I see it.
Avatar
Mr. P. Kiwi
97 Posts
Posted Feb 10, 2012
Replied 4 days later
So, where's the link to this map?
Avatar
HMW
806 Posts
Posted Feb 14, 2012
Replied 3 days later
Yes, I'd say go ahead and release it!

From your screenshots it looks like there's plenty to explore, especially if it has unlockable parts. The problem with most other "playground" maps I've seen, is that they're just variations on the "one big room with every test element in it" theme, which gets boring pretty quickly.

Your map looks almost like a playable style guide for the different test chamber themes, which is a useful thing to have all by itself, not even counting actual playability :smile:

Mr. P. Kiwi wrote:
So, where's the link to this map?

He hasn't uploaded the map yet, he's just asking whether it's okay to upload it. There'll be a link soon hopefully :smile:

Advertisement
Registered users don’t see ads! Register now!
Avatar
portal2companioncube
108 Posts
Posted Feb 14, 2012
Replied 3 hours later
I'm with everyone else.