Speculation with portals

Avatar
jrlauer
545 Posts
Posted Jul 08, 2009
Replied 4 hours later

Ricotez wrote:
My brains hurt after thinking about this, but I'd say yes.

Anyone ever seen Monsters, Inc or the animated short Presto? Both made by Pixar, both using the concept of portals, both freaking hilarious. You can see Presto on Youtube; since I'm not sure if it's there legally, I'm not supplying a link. Searching for "Pixar Presto" should do the trick.

I saw both of those too. They are hilarious. I think Presto is on the beginning of WALL-E isn't it?

Advertisement
Registered users don't see ads! Register now!
Avatar
theVDude
120 Posts
Posted Jul 08, 2009
Replied 4 hours later
So instead of portal through portal, we should ask about hat through hat?

At the portal passing over you, I assumed you would, but I'm not really sure why. It just seems like you would. Which would be extremely painful, since your head would start moving at the speed of the portal before the rest of you.

Ouch.

Avatar
pestchamber
614 Posts
Posted Jul 08, 2009
Replied 38 minutes later

theVDude wrote:
So instead of portal through portal, we should ask about hat through hat?

At the portal passing over you, I assumed you would, but I'm not really sure why. It just seems like you would. Which would be extremely painful, since your head would start moving at the speed of the portal before the rest of you.

Ouch.

Yeah that pretty much makes me say no. Because it makes no sense that something going through a person should make HIM speed up.

Avatar
theVDude
120 Posts
Posted Jul 12, 2009
Replied 3 days later
Well, I did a bit more thinking about it. It really depends. I'm sure it could be coded so that it does or doesn't.

If it did, the reasoning would be that the portals don't care if they're moving, it's what's moving through them. If they didn't, it would take into consideration the speed of the portal and such.

If it DID, portals on fast moving pistons could used to launch yourself to quite a height, with minimal elevation.

That'd be cool.

Avatar
portalgrinder
44 Posts
Posted Jul 14, 2009
Replied 2 days later
I think that you would gain as much speed as the portal comming at you, if the exit portal is not moving.

If you'd hit a brick wall at 100 mph or if that brick wall was comming at you at 100 mph, the effect would be the same. You'd get squish with the same velocity in both situation.

In the case that the exit portal would be moving, i guess it could increase, decrease or change your trajectory, depending of the dirrection it is moving. This is mind bugling...

Avatar
ASBusinessMagnet
490 Posts
Posted Jul 14, 2009
Replied 9 hours later

theVDude wrote:
Which would be extremely painful, since your head would start moving at the speed of the portal before the rest of you.

Ouch.

But actually you wouldn't notice any pain, because no part of your body would be moving relatively to another. Busted.

Avatar
theVDude
120 Posts
Posted Jul 14, 2009
Replied 1 hour later
Good point.
Avatar
portalgrinder
44 Posts
Posted Jul 15, 2009
Replied 4 hours later
My neck hurt like hell... maybe flinging my head could be a good therapy
Avatar
Strigoides
1 Posts
Posted Aug 06, 2009
Replied 21 days later
On another note, if you place a portal on a wall and a camera is there, it falls off right? But if portal are 2-dimensional, where do you draw the line as to what falls off?The paint on the wall?The dirt/dust?
Avatar
pestchamber
614 Posts
Posted Aug 06, 2009
Replied 2 hours later

Strigoides wrote:
On another note, if you place a portal on a wall and a camera is there, it falls off right? But if portal are 2-dimensional, where do you draw the line as to what falls off?The paint on the wall?The dirt/dust?

It would in real life.

Advertisement
Registered users don't see ads! Register now!
Avatar
ASBusinessMagnet
490 Posts
Posted Aug 06, 2009
Replied 5 hours later

pestchamber wrote:
It would in real life.

But then if you place a portal on regular concrete, would it become as flat as a mirror?