Speculation with portals

Avatar
zaldos
18 Posts
Posted Oct 30, 2008
Replied 7 hours later
head explodes. Isnt this thread about what happens in certain condition or whatever.
Advertisement
Registered users don't see ads! Register now!
Avatar
Ricotez
738 Posts
Posted Oct 30, 2008
Replied 4 hours later
This is science.

The science behind Portal.

GUYZ ARENT WE BIG HL NERDZ

Avatar
TiMeMaSTeR
24 Posts
Posted Oct 30, 2008
Replied 5 hours later
WE ARE BIG HL2 NERDZ!!!!

Its hilarious how I tend to talk about quantum physics on forums than other things.

Avatar
msleeper
4,095 Posts
Member
Posted Oct 30, 2008
Replied 3 hours later

TiMeMaSTeR wrote:
WE ARE BIG HL2 NERDZ!!!!

Its hilarious how I tend to talk about quantum physics on forums than other things.

Unless you have a PhD, you're probably just making shit up and/or copy pasting from Wikipedia.

Avatar
Ricotez
738 Posts
Posted Oct 31, 2008
Replied 13 hours later
You don't need a PhD to know quantum physics.

You only need it to understand them.

Avatar
TiMeMaSTeR
24 Posts
Posted Oct 31, 2008
Replied 6 hours later
Exactly. Thinking more about it, Quantum physics is my expetise, its more M-theory and the like.
Avatar
msleeper
4,095 Posts
Member
Posted Oct 31, 2008
Replied 1 hour later

I think this basically sums it up.

TiMeMaSTeR wrote:
Quantum physics is my expetise.

Avatar
Hober
1,180 Posts
Posted Oct 31, 2008
Replied 2 hours later
Maybe he's Italian ... ?
Avatar
Ricotez
738 Posts
Posted Nov 02, 2008
Replied 1 day later
The R-key sits between the E- and the T-key. I guess you could miss it if you type very fast.

That's typology, another branch of nerd science.

Anyways, to return to the topic: What would happen if you open 2 portals, and then move 1 portal with the speed of light whilst the other remains at it place? (Dropping the fact that the portals can't move in-game. 'Cause they do move. You'd only have to take a look at Earth, which rotates at a very high velocity around it's own axis. Then I don't even count the Earth's cycling around the Sun, the Sun's cycling around the center of the Galaxy, and the Galaxy's runaway speed fleeing from the center of the Universe, moving with the expansion of it)

Would you get a portal through time and space instead of only space?

Avatar
TiMeMaSTeR
24 Posts
Posted Nov 02, 2008
Replied 36 minutes later
Possibly, since the portal would then end up younger than the other one because it moved at the speed of light.

And i do type very fast, thank you very much.

Avatar
Hober
1,180 Posts
Posted Nov 02, 2008
Replied 7 hours later

Ricotez wrote:
(Dropping the fact that the portals can't move in-game. 'Cause they do move. You'd only have to take a look at Earth, which rotates at a very high velocity around it's own axis. ...

I would posit that, like most things where Earth's rotation is brought in as a counter-example, it has to do with frame of reference. We define "moving" and "still" in the frame of reference of our surroundings, which are also moving. On an absolute scale, we're all moving massively fast, away from the Big Bang, around the galaxy, around the Sun and so forth as you mention.

The thing is: physics doesn't care. It only cares about how fast you're moving relative to the system you're examining. See what I mean?

My guess is that the two portals have to keep the same velocity relative to each other to stay connected. If they were on both sides of a rocketship and the rocket changed velocities, maybe the portals would stay open. (However, my instinct is now telling me that if you put two portals side by side on a moving wall-section and moved it, both would close, despite maintaining identical momentums. Hmm.)

Avatar
madcat1030
66 Posts
Posted Nov 07, 2008
Replied 5 days later
A couple pages back, somebody said that the universe is endless. I don't believe thats correct. I've read my share of scientific articles, and I'm pretty sure that the general scientific community agrees (for the most part) that the UNIVERSE was BORN out of an infinitely dense particle, blah blah blah. BUT! That particle had to be SOMEWHERE. That SOMEWHERE wasn't the universe, it was somewhere unnamed by human sciences (as far as I know). The universe is only as big as the oldest waves from the original expansion have traveled, which we know for a fact to be a limited number, as we HAVE measured the distance to the oldest particles, and they exhibit a red-shift, meaning that they [the boundary of the Universe] are moving away, but into what? It can't be farther into the universe, because that is where it ends. The universe is filled with sparsely spread (double-ftw) particles. Space is a NEAR-vacuum. There ARE, however, particles. "Space" as we know it only stretches as far as the afore-mentioned universal wall. The area beyond that wall is undefined, and is impossible to define unless we would manage to get there someday (unlikely), but is assumed to be a true vacuum, lacking in ANYTHING. Other hypotheses state that there may be other universes past our barrier, and that as we grow, they shrink, only to expand again when they have been forced into a single particle, causing our universe to begin to shrink. That is where the new theory, the big bounce, could fit in as well, but I believe (not sure) that the big bounce doesn't yet account for other universes.

Anyway, I like portals, and I think that, were it not for engine limitations (or practical ones), that they WOULD move with platforms. I'm working on a mod, and I have it explained to the Test Subject early on that only one thing cannot travel through them, sound.

Avatar
Duffers
474 Posts
Posted Nov 07, 2008
Replied 1 hour later

madcat1030 wrote:
A couple pages back, somebody said that the universe is endless. I don't believe thats correct.

Common sense tells us space is infinite nothingness. It's space. Nothin' out there. I don't get why we need all these retarded speculations of other universes. Seriously. It's Just SPAAAAAAAAAAACE. It doesn't ned to be created by a big bang, or be classified as infinite or finite, it's just NOTHINGNESS.

Avatar
rokie24
12 Posts
Posted Jan 03, 2009
Replied 1 month later
If space is pure nothingness then I have a lot of space where my brain is supposed to be...
Avatar
penapappa
186 Posts
Posted Jun 13, 2009
Replied 5 months later
LOL I actually tried to make that impossible scenario, and I didn't fail at all I got managed to make two portals at same coordinate at same time without that another one fizzles. I actually faked it, I used two prop_portals and deactivated them. Then made 10-100 x trigger_multiple to open a new portal when last one is fizzled, this for both portals in two separated time layers, so they both will stay open and reopen so fast that human eye can't see the "secret". I used box to trigger the trigger. I have picture of it, it's kinda mindfuck

This one fuckt up my pc pretty badly...

Avatar
pestchamber
614 Posts
Posted Jun 13, 2009
Replied 5 hours later

penapappa wrote:
LOL I actually tried to make that impossible scenario, and I didn't fail at all I got managed to make two portals at same coordinate at same time without that another one fizzles. I actually faked it, I used two prop_portals and deactivated them. Then made 10-100 x trigger_multiple to open a new portal when last one is fizzled, this for both portals in two separated time layers, so they both will stay open and reopen so fast that human eye can't see the "secret". I used box to trigger the trigger. I have picture of it, it's kinda mindfuck

This one fuckt up my pc pretty badly...

can you upload the map please? And a vmf?

Avatar
penapappa
186 Posts
Posted Jun 14, 2009
Replied 7 hours later
sure

okay check the wip

Avatar
pestchamber
614 Posts
Posted Jun 14, 2009
Replied 1 hour later

penapappa wrote:
sure

okay check the wip

Thanks!

EDIT:
Lol, That's really cool! but i lagg alot when the portal's are open :p

Avatar
theVDude
120 Posts
Posted Jul 08, 2009
Replied 23 days later
I read this whole thread.

Yes, yes I did. And I few things to say that were already said, but I'd like to post something that shows I'm not a retard.

On the topic of portals bending 4space and "flatlanders" paper portals:
This is EXACTLY right. If you took a sheet of paper, and made two holes, and folded it over to line them up, WE'D see a folded piece of paper. A flatlander, would see a shortcut, you know, a portal, but nothing distorted. So portals, in our 3space, would be bent through 4space. (I'm not running the risk of "the 4th dimension is time"). We wouldn't notice, we'd see a shortcut.

At the rule of not placing a portal between portals (I'll go back and look for that post later) You could fold the paper the other way, so this could work. How many times, I don't know, but in your example, one in the cube one out of the cube works.

Another speculation with moving portals (Please don't bring up relative to each other or portals don't move. I don't really want to hear it. It's a cheap cop-out to thinking, and not what this post is for.)

Say there's 0 on something that's falling toward you, and 0 on a stationary object. When you go through 0 (Or more correctly, when it passes over you, do you leave 0 at the speed of 0?

Advertisement
Registered users don't see ads! Register now!
Avatar
Ricotez
738 Posts
Posted Jul 08, 2009
Replied 7 hours later

theVDude wrote:
Say there's 0 on something that's falling toward you, and 0 on a stationary object. When you go through 0 (Or more correctly, when it passes over you, do you leave 0 at the speed of 0?

My brains hurt after thinking about this, but I'd say yes.

Anyone ever seen Monsters, Inc or the animated short Presto? Both made by Pixar, both using the concept of portals, both freaking hilarious. You can see Presto on Youtube; since I'm not sure if it's there legally, I'm not supplying a link. Searching for "Pixar Presto" should do the trick.