By the way, rating currently works (though you can rate multiple times if you refresh the page...shhhh), I just need to make the images more interactive.

I am genius.

Kizzycocoa wrote:
I am strategically re-voting to "depends on map type". this way, cake can STILL win.

I am genius.

You also created a stalemate.

Regardless I think the voting passed already, so any input now won't do much. It's prolly going to be Portals.

HOWEVER, I suggest for featured maps (also, we doing featured maps?) that we have a little cake icon appear over the thumbnail. Basically the test approved icon i've seen floating about with a cake in it. That way we have a cake and relevant rating icons to both games.

I think the test approved icon was what we were going to use for featured maps/mods, no cakes about it.

groxkiller585 wrote:

Kizzycocoa wrote:
I am strategically re-voting to "depends on map type". this way, cake can STILL win.

I am genius. >

You also created a stalemate.

Regardless I think the voting passed already

Hey, beats a checkmate.

also, NEVER. cake will always win out in the end.
always.

Kizzycocoa wrote:

groxkiller585 wrote:

Kizzycocoa wrote:
I am strategically re-voting to "depends on map type". this way, cake can STILL win.

I am genius. >>

You also created a stalemate.

Regardless I think the voting passed already>
Hey, beats a checkmate.

also, NEVER. cake will always win out in the end.
always.

Sorry, cake lost to the entire point of the game.

Cake is powerful, yes, but without Portals Cake would not exist in such a powerful form.

Therefore Portals.

groxkiller585 wrote:
without Portals Cake would not exist in such a powerful form.

I beg to differ.

Cake was the main goal of the most popular game of my youth. It played the most important part in the most famous game icon ever's first game.

Need I say more?

Kizzycocoa wrote:
snip

I beg to differ.

Cake was the main goal of the most popular game of my youth. It played the most important part in the most famous game icon ever's first game.

Need I say more?

You don't, but I do. SM64 was NOT the first Mario game. It was the first 3D Mario game.

Second off, the cake is mentioned twice: Once at the very beginning as a (now thinking on it funny) excuse for Mario to be coming to her castle, and at the very end when the entire deal is won and he can finally eat it.

In Portal, it's brought up a lot more, used as incentive to get you back into the chambers multiple times and finally is shown at the end to actually exist. It's part of Portal's lore. It's not part of Mario's lore.

Besides, if you'd ask anyone about a video game where cake was an important factor that came up a lot, Portal would be the winner.

And don't even try to drag Minecraft into this because we all know Minecraft's cake was A. suggested by you and B. was inspired by Portal, which btw proves my point.

/blowingasmallarguementhugelyoutofpreportionbecausehewantedto

Pilchard123 wrote:
Oh come on! You never seriously though that the cake was a the real reason that Toadstool invited Mario the her castle, did you?

I was like 5, so yes. I did.

But they don't give any other reason (that's not even implied...ever) so I find it hilarious that that's the only reason he came was for food. He's like Kirby in that aspect. XP

Pilchard123 wrote:
Fair enough. I first played the DS remake of it when I was rather older than 5, so unfortunately I already knew about Rule 34.

I played the original, and loved every second of it

Another favorite game of mine was Donkey Kong 64.

[yt:1aagij0p]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J2y-n88iZSc[/yt:1aagij0p]

groxkiller585 wrote:
the cake is mentioned twice: Once at the very beginning as a (now thinking on it funny) excuse for Mario to be coming to her castle, and at the very end when the entire deal is won and he can finally eat it.

In Portal, it's brought up a lot more, used as incentive to get you back into the chambers multiple times and finally is shown at the end to actually exist. It's part of Portal's lore. It's not part of Mario's lore.

Regardless of lore, cake was used in there first as an incentive. it may have been subtle, yes. but it was always there. and was the final screen of the game.

groxkiller585 wrote:
Besides, if you'd ask anyone about a video game where cake was an important factor that came up a lot, Portal would be the winner.

Public opinion is irrelevant to arguments of logic

groxkiller585 wrote:
And don't even try to drag Minecraft into this because we all know Minecraft's cake was A. suggested by you and B. was inspired by Portal, which btw proves my point.

That is totally a lie. that statement, not the cake.

For one, it was my "friends" who asked. I clearly asked on behalf of them. this is totally a true thing that happened.
For two, who knows if they knew of portal at all???????? no-one, that's who. so oh well.

Pilchard123 wrote:
Oh come on! You never seriously though that the cake was a the real reason that Toadstool invited Mario the her castle, did you?

MY ENTIRE GAMING CHILDHOOD HAS BEEN RUINED.
great one. you tied 34 and mario
I shall never play it the same again.

now just destroy World of Illusion on SEGA, and you've completely ruined my entire innocent gaming childhood :c

p0rtalplayer wrote:
Looks like Democracy has Ruled Again: It shall be Portals.

Cave Johnson. We're done here.

vanSulli wrote:
I know this is 'innocent' discussion and that there's no inherent harm in it, but let's steer ourselves away from this tangent.

p0rtalplayer wrote:
Looks like Democracy has Ruled Again: It shall be Portals.>

Cave Johnson. We're done here.

I vote for a recount of votes! I call voter fraud!

as I am a constituent of the forum, I demand a recount, or I shall vote against anyone supporting portals in the next election!

Kizzycocoa wrote:
For two, who knows if they knew of portal at all

The achievement for making a cake is called "The Lie".

lol@voterfraud. In Real Life sure, but not on this forum. I know a certain AI would that never like cheating on this site...

As Van said it was already decided. Sorry Kizzy :c

groxkiller585 wrote:

Kizzycocoa wrote:
For two, who knows if they knew of portal at all>

The achievement for making a cake is called "The Lie".

lol@voterfraud. In Real Life sure, but not on this forum. I know a certain AI would that never like cheating on this site...

As Van said it was already decided. Sorry Kizzy :c

Lies! Nothing is set it concrete that can't be reedited! Not even old!Aperture.

(off topic:for something sealed off forever, old!aperture seemed easy to reopen.)